Breaking Down How ‘Love at First Sight’ Compares to YA Novel Inspiration

Haley Lu Richardson and Ben Hardy star in our latest Netflix romantic comedy obsession, Love at First Sight, which was adapted from Jennifer E. Smith’s 2012 novel of a nearly identical name.

Smith’s The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight kicked off with high school senior Hadley Sullivan narrowly missing her flight to London for her dad’s second wedding. Her replacement flight seats her beside British college student Oliver, who is returning home for a funeral. Throughout the course of the novel, the twosome connect over life, love and everything in between — in a single day.

It was announced in April 2022 that Netflix planned to bring Smith’s bestselling words to life starring Richardson and Hardy as Hadley and Oliver, respectively.

“They’ve shortened the title, but it’s still the same story you’ve loved all these years, and I hope you’ll love the film version just as much,” Smith wrote via Instagram in January, referring to the film’s abbreviated name.

Best Rom-Coms to Watch When You’re Stuck at Home

Related: Best Rom-Coms to Watch When You’re Stuck at Home

Romance for all! Whether you’re stuck at home due to inclement weather, or simply want a night in, Us Weekly has the perfect must-watch movie list for indoor viewing. While some fans may opt for social media quizzes or binge-watching a new show, others choose to break out their go-to romantic comedies during a long weekend […]

Love at First Sight premiered Friday, September 15, on Netflix.

Keep reading for a breakdown of how Love at First Sight compares to its literary inspiration:

Age Gaps

While the book versions of Hadley and Oliver are 17 and 18, respectively, they’ve been aged up for the big screen treatment. In the film, Hadley is 20 and Oliver is two years older than her at 22.

Breaking Down How Netflix's 'Love at First Sight' Compares to Jennifer E. Smith's Young Adult Novel
Haley Lu Richardson as Hadley Sullivan and Ben Hardy as Oliver Jones in ‘Love at First Sight.’ Courtesy of Netflix

Descriptive Discrepancies 

Eagle-eyed book lovers will note that the movie took a few liberties with some minuscule details, especially in regard to Hadley’s bridesmaid dress (maroon in color instead of lavender) and the location and venue of Hadley and Oliver’s respective events. (For what it is worth: Shoreditch and Kensington are two very distinct areas in London, as are Paddington and Peckham.)

Perhaps the biggest change was the plane seating configuration. In The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight, Hadley and Oliver are assigned the window and aisle seats in row 18. (Oliver ends up taking the middle seat to chat with Hadley, switching spots with an older woman.) In the Netflix flick, they both end up seated in a business-class two-seater.

A New Addition

There is no narrator as a person in the book, which meant a role was added in the film for Jameela Jamil. The Good Place alum even popped into various scenes as different characters to help move the story along.

'The Other Black Girl' and More TV Shows That Are Based on Books

Related: TV Shows and Movies That Are Based on Books

Little Fires Everywhere, Big Little Lies and You are among the best-selling books that made their way to the small screen in the form of TV adaptations. Reese Witherspoon is at the center of many of the most successful TV shows based on books, thanks to her passion for bringing fresh stories to a new […]

Oliver’s Entire Backstory

Oliver,  who is given the surname Jones in the movie despite never having a last name in the novel, has a completely different background. In the book, he is the youngest of three boys and is estranged from his father, whose funeral he was set to attend. In the movie, Oliver just has one brother and he is close to his happily married parents. The funeral is a “living memorial” for his mother, who is dying of cancer.

The new backstory allowed viewers to also see the story from Oliver’s side instead of solely Hadley’s point-of-view like the novel.

Breaking Down How Netflix's 'Love at First Sight' Compares to Jennifer E. Smith's Young Adult Novel
Haley Lu Richardson as Hadley Sullivan and Ben Hardy as Oliver Jones in ‘Love at First Sight.’ Courtesy of Netflix

Losing an Entire Character — or Two

While Hadley was upset with her dad, Andrew Sullivan, in both the book and movie for leaving her family post-divorce, she leaned on her mom on the page. Hadley’s mother was not featured in the movie nor was Hadley’s almost-stepfather Harrison. (Movie Hadley’s phobia of dentists had Us wondering if it was a subtle reference to Harrison’s dental profession.)

Inside the ‘Memorial’

With the movie giving more access to Oliver, it also allowed fans (and Hadley) to go into his mom’s memorial and meet his family. As pointed out above, the tweak allows viewers to see Oliver’s emotions and vulnerabilities whereas he was a fairly one-dimensional book love interest.


Related: Haley Lu Richardson and Ex-Fiance Brett Dier: The Way They Were

After meeting on set of Ravenswood, Haley Lu Richardson and Brett Dier were actual relationship goals before they called it quits. The Pretty Little Liars spinoff, which premiered in 2013, only lasted one season on ABC Family (now Freeform) but that was enough time for Richardson and Dier to hit it off. “We met on […]

A Dickensian Connection

Book Hadley and her dad had a huge bond over Charles Dickens and his novel Our Mutual Friend. The movie left that connection completely intact.

Breaking Down How Netflix's 'Love at First Sight' Compares to Jennifer E. Smith's Young Adult Novel
Jameela Jamil as Narrator in ‘Love at First Sight.’ Rob Baker Ashton/Netflix

Ripped From the Page

Faithful book readers will be delighted that several exact lines and jokes were replicated in the Netflix script — including the last scene’s final dialogue when Oliver mutters the complete book title for the first time.

A New Ending

The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight ends with the pair reuniting at the end of the day, whereas Jamil’s character gives movie fans a brief “epilogue” of sorts. In a voiceover, she teases where Oliver and Hadley end up long after the onscreen day ends.

Love at First Sight is currently streaming on Netflix.